Medium Format Forum

Register a free account now!

If you are registered, you get access to the members only section, can participate in the buy & sell second hand forum and last but not least you can reserve your preferred username before someone else takes it.

Which lens should I buy?

I am ready to buy my 80mm Planar for my 500ELM. I note there are old stlyes and newer ones . I like the chrome 80mm 2.8, but saw a black finished one of the same design, but it had the red T* on it. I read that it has a better coating. However, almost all my lenses are one coated lenses for my view cameras and regular coating on the rest of them. My equipment is 40 + years old. I simply use a good lens shade and avoid pointing the lens into a light source. Would I not see a difference in these two lenses? My guess is that the color might be a bit more vivid and contrasty with the T*. Can anyone tell me if they can see a difference from their experience of using both lenses? Thank you.
 
The chrome 80mm you like is a C series lenses. There were 3 C series, 1. chrome, coated,,,,,2. black, coated,,,,,, and 3. black with T* coating. I doubt you can see any difference with any of them.

Terry
 
Thank you Terry, I will get the less expensive chrome 80mm Planar. My late friend, Peter Gowland, used it and a 150mm Sonar chrome lens, for many years doing Hollywood movie stars. They have a nice retro look in black and white photos.
 
The chrome 80mm you like is a C series lenses. There were 3 C series, 1. chrome, coated,,,,,2. black, coated,,,,,, and 3. black with T* coating. I doubt you can see any difference with any of them.

Terry

For most C series lenses T* came at the same time as the black barrels.

There are some exceptions:

40 mm C lenses were only available as black barrel lenses.
Early 40 mm C lenses do not have T* coating.

The 50 mm silver lens started with early coating.
Before the barrel changed to black small number of silver T* lenses were produced.
IQ of these lenses is the same as black barrel T* lenses.

All silver 60 mm lenses have the early coating meaning all black barrel 60 mm lenses have T*

For 80 mm lenses T* was introduced before the black barrel became available.
A larger number of the 80 mm silver Planar than 50 mm silver C lenses were offered with T* .
Sorry Terry, this means all black 80 mm C lenses have T*.

To make matters even more confusing there are also some black barrel lenses that were not supplied with T* glass.
The 100 mm Planar black barrel started life without T* and some 150 Sonnar lenses were available with black barrels without T*

Even more confusing some non T* lenses were fitted later with T* glass because a front and or rear lens was damaged in use.

After this chaos the question comes up how important is T* coating?
Only under exceptional conditions will T* be a significant improvement.
Extreme back lit scenes may show a difference expecially for images recorded without the use of a suitable pro shade.
To prevent unwanted flare an effective lens shade does more than T*.


Vic.
 
Back
Top